Middle-Income families eat more fast food than low-income families, but are less obese

Middle-income families more likely to eat fast food than poor families

Fast food is not entirely to blame for high rate of low-income obesity

Published in the California Aggie (theaggie.org) on November 9, 2011

Article and Photo by Hudson Lofchie


omedian Richard Jeni once said, “one out of every three Americans weighs as much as the other two.” That was the part of his act that was not supposed to be funny.

Fast food has received a bad rap as being the primary cause of obesity, but a recent study by UC Davis researchers has found that fast food is more common among middle-income families than it is among low-income families. Those same middle-income families also have lower rates of obesity than low-income families.

“For the very poor, fast food is not the biggest factor [in obesity],” said Paul Leigh, a professor of public health sciences at UC Davis and lead author of the study.

There is a direct coloration between lower income and increased obesity rates, but if fast food isn’t the cause of low-income obesity, what is?  There are a few other factors that lead to higher obesity rates in low-income families.

Elizabeth Applegate, director of sports nutrition at UC Davis said that obesity is caused by a discrepancy between how many calories are taken in, versus how many are being burned — what she calls the “energy balance equation.”

“If output doesn’t equal input, obesity develops over time,” she said.

When money is tight, priority is put on cost-per-calorie, which means that poor families will buy highly processed carbohydrates, food with saturated fats and sugar-rich sodas and snacks — empty calories. Furthermore, lower-income neighborhoods are generally not as safe as middle and upper-income neighborhoods so children do not receive the recommended 60 minutes of physical activity per day.

“The rate of aging is probably set during development years,” said Roger McDonald, a professor of nutrition at UC Davis. “The reality is that the only two things that will slow down aging are keeping weight off and staying active.”

There are serious health problems that come from obesity: cardiovascular problems and insulin resistance, just to name a few.

“There has been an explosion in cases of Type 2 Diabetes,” said Judith Stern of the UC Davis nutrition department.

Obesity is not just a health concern, but a social concern as well. Obese children are often the targets of bullying, and obesity-related complications cost the health care system $147 billion in 2008.

There is no single person or institution that can be blamed for the easy access to unhealthy foods. Over the past decade, the manufacture of refined carbohydrates has become far less expensive, and fats used in cooking are easier to produce. The U.S. government also spends $17 billion annually subsidizing grain farmers. This makes empty calories even cheaper.

There are a few ways to fix these issues. According to Leigh, there needs to cheap, healthy alternatives to the unhealthy foods on fast food menus, as well as government subsidies for healthy choices. He also believes that there should be a tax on sugary sodas and that the proceeds should go to fund food stamps.

Applegate suggests that neighborhoods create an environment for safe physical activity.

“Davis is a model community,” Applegate said. “There are bike paths, farmers markets with organic food and parents here know the importance of activity and nutrition. Davis is fitness utopia.”

Some fast food chains have begun to address these issues in their own way.

“McDonalds has done a good job of creating awareness through labeling calories on their menu boards,” Stern said.

“We need to promote both sides of the energy equation,” Applegate said. “I compliment McDonalds. They offer play areas which are a safe place for calorie burning.”

Applegate said that kids who eat healthy and are physically active are not only healthier later in life, they have better blood flow, better attention span, better mental acuity and even higher scores on standardized tests.


2 thoughts on “Middle-Income families eat more fast food than low-income families, but are less obese

  1. Fast food is slowly killing us. I am not surprised that the middle income families are eating more because of the insane schedules that they have. Parents just don’t have the energy to make dinner for their families after a long day at work. The video game industry is also a huge contributing factor.

    The thing that really gets my panties in a wad is the way the fast food companies market to the little ones….it’s disgusting.

    I disagree with the tax just on sodas as fries, onion rings, ice cream…etc etc. is just as unhealthy….why not tax those too?
    It all starts with early education. Kids need to see what real food looks like and where it comes from.

  2. An outstanding share! I have just forwarded this onto a colleague who has been doing a little research on
    this. And he actually ordered me lunch because I stumbled upon it for him.
    .. lol. So allow me to reword this…. Thanks for the meal!
    ! But yeah, thanks for spending time to talk about this matter here on your site.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s